Proof texting

Proof-texting is the use of out-of-context quotes to support an argument or it can be defined as the use of individual scripture texts to produce apparent support for a doctrinal position without adequate regard for the contexts of the individual texts. 


This is not including texts for illustration or texts used in its proper context. Rowland Croucher says of proof texters in one of his blog post: Proof texters would much rather have a short list of texts that support precisely what they have decided to believe instead of spending the time to know exactly what each writer teaches about the complete doctrine. Croucher goes on to say the purveyor of proof-texts can appear to be wonderfully informed and a deep scholar of the Bible. 

This sort of thing can be carried into the pulpit as well. Sermon proof texting is a preaching style that often uses many scripture quotes in one sermon. Each scripture is intended to build the point or points. The problem with this preaching style is that the context is usually lost by the third or fourth scripture citation, if it was ever established at all.

This sermon style and teaching style is comforting to the members because they can see their belief system powerfully laid out in scripture upon scripture, like a beloved memorized tract. If they don’t hear those familiar themes comfortingly repeated as a ritual week after week they most likely do not get excited.  

The biggest issue that arises from contextless sermons and teaching is that it does not edify those who really want their understanding of God to be expanded and empowered to be able to face the stresses and temptations of life.

Be on guard and study for yourself. Have your preachers and teachers stand accountable for teaching the word of God in its proper context so that you can be sure you are absorbing the mind of God.